“End Nuclear Insanity Before Nuclear Insanity Ends Humanity”
Aug 06, 2024
Image of a nuclear power station in France (from the EastMojo Article below)
LAW’s NUCLEAR ISSUES & COMMENTS, Monday, (08/05/2024)
Australia has never accepted the idea of nuclear power plants on Australian soil, except for the one mentioned in the story, which is a small reactor for medical products, (the USA’s mysterious military project at Pine Gap near Alice Springs is not mentioned), but Australia would be well-advised to always keep themselves ‘clean’ of any future nuclear projects. This article reminded me of the old novel and movie, “On the Beach”, where the last living souls were the only remaining humans left alive after a nuclear accident, apparently in the USA.
I am surprised that “On the Beach” was not mentioned as one of the more important pop culture films of all time. It was, written by Nevil Shute, published in 1957, made into the referenced major movie in 1959, and there have been two other movie remakes of the story in the early 2000s. But the author’s point is well-made — that ‘all things nuclear’ are a liability we do not want to continue to grow because the pop-culture and its horrifying images of the dark side of nuclear power and nuclear war are enough to drive us away. ~llaw
Northeast India News, Assam News, Breaking News of Northeast | Latest News Live | EastMojo
Everything I know about nuclear power I learnt from The Simpsons
By Marcus K. Harmes, University of Southern Queensland and Michael B. Charles, Southern Cross University in Toowoomba
by 360info.org17 hours ago
Pop culture is likely to be the main way most Australians have learnt about nuclear power. What impact will this have on shaping their views of the technology?
What connects The Simpsons, Doctor Who and HBO’s Chernobyl?
These — along with many other film and television productions — parody, problematise or otherwise show us nuclear power stations in action and, of course, in meltdown.
Such pop culture representations are the closest many Australians will have come to experiencing the nuclear world.
And that could affect what they think of opposition leader Peter Dutton’s proposal to build seven nuclear power plants if elected.
Pop culture has significant potential to influence people’s thinking on important topics. In particular, it informs the frames of reference that people use to form views about controversial issues.
From belief in conspiracy theories, to role models, to the way music can promote racial justice, pop culture powerfully influences the way people perceive themselves and the world.
It has likely played a considerable role in shaping the way Australians think about nuclear power, especially given that Australians have very minimal actual experience with nuclear energy.
There is only one nuclear reactor in Australia, in Lucas Heights, a southern suburb of Sydney. However, unlike the plants in The Simpsons and other pop culture examples, it is used strictly for nuclear medicine and research, not to generate power.
While the day-to-day reality of nuclear energy is largely unknown in Australia — unlike countries such as France where nuclear power stations are largely an everyday part of the landscape — one doesn’t have to look too far to find fictitious and potentially misleading references to nuclear power.
Mr C. Montgomery Burns’ nuclear power plant in The Simpsons is the most prominent and longstanding example in pop culture.
Homer Simpson has spent his entire working life in sector 7G of this power plant as (hilariously) its safety officer.
Mr Burns’ plant has gone into meltdown several times, been condemned for literally hundreds of safety violations, caused strange mutations in local wildlife, leaked radioactive waste into the water supply, caught fire and in general simply loomed above the town of Springfield, its two cooling towers marked with the symbol of atomic energy.
Of course The Simpsons is a cartoon with the inbuilt “reset” switch allowing for any scenario to be undone by the next episode.
Chernobyl and other disasters
HBO’s Chernobyl in contrast shows the terrifying irreversibility of an actual disaster in a nuclear power plant.
Chillingly, the Chernobyl plant is back in the news as one of the battle sites in the war between Ukraine and Russia, with Russian troops choosing to dig into the radioactive soil, while their tanks throw red dust from contaminated sites into the air.
In 1979 the film The China Syndrome pointed to what might happen if nuclear energy is not managed properly.
This Hollywood drama about corruption, coverup and the danger of meltdown in a nuclear power station came into cinemas just days before the actual nuclear accident at Three Mile Island in the United States.
Strikingly, these dramas present the exact same nuclear anxieties and threats as do The Simpsons.
But whereas The Simpsons is a comedy, these other works make it clear that there would be environmental and human disaster if a power plant went into a full meltdown scenario.
In 1991, when the 1986 Chernobyl incident was still fresh, Anglia Television dramatised the murder mystery Devices and Desiresby the British crime writer P.D. James.
Set in and around the fictional Larksoken Nuclear Power Plant, the production filmed on location at the Sizewell Power Station in Norfolk.
The fact the authorities at Sizewell gave permission is surprising as the miniseries takes every opportunity to make nuclear energy look as ominous as it can.
On the soundtrack, warning sirens and the nuclear reactors drone and wail, characters allude anxiously to Chernobyl and the possibility of a meltdown caused by computer hacking. The series even suggests that the actions of a local serial killer may be somehow linked to the effect of nuclear energy on the environment!
Of course, there are no known links between nuclear energy and psychopathic behaviour, but the generally negative attitude to nuclear power seen in popular culture means that outlandish claims and associations can go uncontested, and indeed might even seem plausible.
British television also presented nuclear power stations as places of inherent drama and danger in Doctor Who.
In the 1970 story Doctor Who and the Silurians, a nuclear-powered cyclotron (a type of particle accelerator) went into dangerous levels of overload, posing the same threat that would actually happen at Chernobyl 16 years later: large swathes of the country becoming irradiated.
In these examples the nuclear power is at the service of drama, which extracts tension from the risk of nuclear accidents.
In reality, nuclear power stations have inherent (built-in) safety features. While Chernobyl and Fukishima were famous incidents, they are the only two major accidents in the documented 18,500 reactor years of nuclear-generated power.
Another important consideration is that nuclear weapons, nuclear experimentation and nuclear energy are often conflated in pop culture.
This reinforces the concept of nuclear anything being dangerous to both people and to the environment.
Mutants and monsters
In 1996’s Independence Day, the character played by Jeff Goldblum wants to save the planet and is concerned with things like recycling and scolding people who don’t do so, but baulks at the use of nuclear weapons to destroy the extraterrestrials threatening earth.
Yet the nukes don’t stop the extraterrestrial invaders when deployed and humanity has to come up with a smarter solution to defeat the aliens.
Nuclear experimentation and associated outcomes such as radioactivity also results in ordinary people — or even certain ninja turtles named after Renaissance masters — being given generally helpful superpowers, such as Dr Manhattan in Watchmen and the various reimaginings of Peter Parker aka Spider-Man.
But it also results in uncontrollable monsters such as what we see in the Godzilla films, with Godzilla and similarly awakened monstrous creatures from the deep representing physical manifestations of what happens when humans try to “play God” with nuclear testing.
Nuclear energy has also been depicted as a dangerous and primitive source of energy that will soon become dated.
In Star Trek IV: The Voyage Home, Mr Spock, the Enterprise’s science officer, describes fission reactors — that is, conventional nuclear power — as having been phased out in the fusion era.
Nuclear power is thus seen in science fiction as a dangerous 20th century experiment on the way to more genuinely sustainable — and safer — forms of energy.
Such depictions work against the federal opposition’s plan to present nuclear power as a reliable and safe day-to-day energy source and hence clearly differentiate themselves from the Labor government on energy policy.
To get there however, Australians will need to divorce themselves from the predominantly ominous nature of nuclear energy that is presented in pop culture.
Clearly, nuclear power needs to be assessed according to its economic and scientific merits rather than the hyperbolic, and literally cartoonish, depictions of it in pop culture.
But nuclear energy being almost always presented as dangerous, unreliable and experimental assists the narrative of renewables being the safer long-term alternative.
Indeed, pop culture asks us to consider: if somebody as logical as Mr Spock didn’t think that nuclear power had much of a future, should we?
Professor Marcus K. Harmes teaches in the Pathways Program and the Bachelor of Laws at the University of Southern Queensland. His research is focused on science fiction and popular culture (especially Doctor Who), the cultural history of education and education in popular culture.
Associate Professor Michael B. Charles is a member of the Faculty of Business, Law and Arts at Southern Cross University. His current research focuses on infrastructure policy, innovation policy and public values, while the bulk of his teaching corresponds to the pursuit of sustainability, especially in the arena of transport.
Originally published under Creative Commons by 360info™.
Subscribe
ABOUT THE FOLLOWING ACCESS TO “LLAW’S ALL THINGS NUCLEAR” RELATED MEDIA:
There are 7 categories, with the latest (#7) being a Friday weekly roundup of IAEA (International Atomic Energy Agency) global nuclear news stories. Also included is a bonus non-nuclear category for news about the Yellowstone caldera and other volcanic and caldera activity around the world that play an important role in humanity’s lives. The feature categories provide articles and information about ‘all things nuclear’ for you to pick from, usually with up to 3 links with headlines concerning the most important media stories in each category, but sometimes fewer and occasionally even none (especially so with the Yellowstone Caldera). The Categories are listed below in their usual order:
- All Things Nuclear
- Nuclear Power
- Nuclear Power Emergencies
- Nuclear War
- Nuclear War Threats
- Yellowstone Caldera (Note: There are no Yellowstone Caldera bonus stories available in this evening’s Post.)
- IAEA Weekly News (Friday’s only)
Whenever there is an underlined link to a Category media news story, if you press or click on the link provided, you no longer have to cut and paste to your web browser, since this Post’s link will take you directly to the article in your browser.
A current Digest of major nuclear media headlines with automated links is listed below by nuclear Category (in the above listed order). If a Category heading does not appear in the daily news Digest, it means there was no news reported from this Category today. Generally, the three best articles in each Category from around the nuclear world(s) are Posted. Occasionally, if a Post is important enough, it may be listed in multiple Categories.
TODAY’S NUCLEAR WORLD’S NEWS, Monday, (08/05/2024)
All Things Nuclear
NEWS
North Korean leader marks the delivery of 250 nuclear-capable missile launchers to frontline units
The Hill
… about Kim’s nuclear program have grown as he … all Hill.TV See all Video. Top Stories. See All · Education · Students gearing up for round 2 of pro …
Nuclear Prayer Day: Local church joins global call to end use of atomic weapons
LehighValleyNews.com
… Sign In. DONATE. WLVR. All Things Considered. Next Up: 6:00 PM Fresh Air Weekend. 0:00. 0:00. Available On Air Stations. On Air Now Playing 91.3 WLVR.
Everything I know about nuclear power I learnt from The Simpsons – EastMojo
EastMojo
Everything I know about nuclear power I learnt from The Simpsons. By Marcus K. Harmes, University of Southern Queensland and Michael B. Charles, …
Nuclear Power
NEWS
Majority of Americans support more nuclear power in the country – Pew Research Center
Pew Research Center
The partisan gap in support for nuclear power (18 points) is smaller than those for other types of energy, including fossil fuel sources such as coal …
Milestones for Rajasthan reactors old and new – World Nuclear News
World Nuclear News
Days after unit 3 at the Rajasthan nuclear power plant returned to service after the completion of major refurbishment, fuel loading has begun at …
Nuclear Power Long-Term Growth Could Be Staggering | – ETF Trends
ETF Trends
Nuclear power is experiencing a rebirth of sorts — one some experts believe brings with it robust long-term investment opportunities.
Nuclear Power Emergencies
NEWS
Multiday Deluge from Debby Predicted – South Carolina Emergency Management Division
South Carolina Emergency Management Division
Nuclear Power Plants · Hazardous Materials · Terrorism · Drought · Extreme Heat · Your Emergency Plan · Family Disaster Plan · Financial · Checklists …
FP&L Testing Its Emergency Warning Sirens This Week – WQCS
WQCS
FP&L maintains 91 outdoor emergency warning sirens which are necessary in the unlikely event of an incident at FP&L’s St. Lucie Nuclear Power Plant …
Potassium Iodide Distribution To Be Held For Limerick Nuclear Plant – Patch
Patch
Another event to distribute the emergency medication will be held later this month. · Find out what’s happening in Limerick-Royersford-Spring Citywith …
Nuclear War
NEWS
North Korea Blasts U.S. ‘Nuclear War Plan’ – Newsweek
Newsweek
Pyongyang warned that Washington and its allies would bear the consequences for “provocations” in the region.
North Korean leader marks the delivery of 250 nuclear-capable missile launchers to frontline units
AP News
Concerns about Kim’s nuclear program have grown as he has demonstrated an intent to deploy battlefield nuclear weapons along the North’s border with …
North Korean leader marks the delivery of 250 nuclear-capable missile launchers to frontline units
ABC News – The Walt Disney Company
Catch up on the developing stories from around the globe making headlines. SEOUL, South Korea — North Korea marked …
Nuclear War Threats
NEWS
We recognize two terrible anniversaries to alert public to risk of nuclear war (Viewpoint)
MassLive
And Russia’s threats to use nuclear weapons in Ukraine have underlined the danger of the current situation. Counter threats by NATO have increased the …
Nuclear brinkmanship keeping the world on edge – Tribune India
Tribune India
Pakistan and North Korea have often rattled their nuclear sabre to ward off what they perceive as superior conventional military threats. The …
North Korean leader marks the delivery of 250 nuclear-capable missile launchers to frontline units
The Washington Post
… nuclear program to counter perceived U.S. threats, state media said Monday. … Kim lately has used Russia’s war on Ukraine as a distraction to …