End Nuclear Insanity Before Nuclear Insanity Ends Humanity” ~llaw
Jan 07, 2025
Anna King Image
Northwest News Network
The Hanford Site pictured in 2021. Amazon announced in October that it plans to build nuclear reactors in southeast Washington that would power its data centers in Umatilla and Morrow counties, but many tribes and environmentalists are against it.
LLAW’s NUCLEAR WORLD NEWS TODAY with THE RISKS & CONSEQUENCES OF TOMORROW
Following is a story that could well be the most significant of All Things Nuclear’s environmental warnings, fears, and objections to nuclear power plants, nuclear waste, and military use of nuclear weapons manufacturing and testing operations all around the globe. Only nuclear war itself could or would be more potentially devastating.
If you don’t know about or have forgotten the “Hanford” never-ending nuclear fiasco and seemingly infinite mess that has long plagued agricultural, living conditions, and natural resources in parts of Oregon, Washington, and California, and wetlands, streams, and rivers including the Columbia, a refresher course is a key to this story. Dozens or even hundreds of other places in other countries if Information technology computing companies continue pushing nuclear power reactors at more and more locations, sizes, and habitat imperiled by both nuclear energy facilities, their waste as well as increasingly powerful nuclear stockpiles of weapons of mass destruction by both aggressive and defensive “deterrent” nuclear-arms-possession countries and eventual new ones like Iran and others. ~llaw
Tribes, environmentalists gather forces against Amazon’s Northwest nuclear plan
Oregon Public Broadcasting | By Antonio Sierra
Published January 7, 2025 at 6:44 AM PST
/
NWPB / OPB
Caution signs warn of radioactive materials at the Tank-Side Cesium Removal System process enclosure outside AP Tank Farm on the Hanford Nuclear Reservation, Sept. 24, 2024. Amazon announced in October that it plans to build nuclear reactors in southeast Washington that would power its data centers in Umatilla and Morrow counties, but many tribes and environmentalists are against it.
Amazon’s push for small modular nuclear reactors is just the latest development in decadeslong fight over nuclear energy.
Chuck Johnson was 25 years old when he helped bring Oregon’s nuclear energy industry to a sudden halt.
Fresh out of college, Johnson helped lead signature gathering and field organizing to pass Ballot Measure 7, which banned all new nuclear power plants in the state until the U.S. had a federally licensed permanent disposal facility. When the Oregon’s only nuclear energy facility was closed in 1992, the measure effectively ensured that nothing would take its place unless major changes happened.
For decades those changes seemed unlikely, but a new push by the power-hungry tech industry has reignited interest in nuclear energy in the region.
Amazon announced in October that it is partnering with Energy Northwest to develop and build nuclear reactors in southeast Washington that would power its data centers in Umatilla and Morrow counties. Amazon would work with its partners to develop and roll out a novel technology – small modular nuclear reactors – without brushing up against the limits of Measure 7 because the reactors would be north of the Columbia River.
For Amazon, SMRs would allow the tech and e-commerce giant to harness the immense, low-carbon power potential of nuclear energy while staying true to its climate goals, and avoiding the safety and environmental concerns that have plagued traditional reactors. More than 40 years after passing Measure 7, Johnson isn’t convinced.
“If you can’t get rid of the waste produced by these plants, it’s irresponsible for us to – for the sake of some electricity right now – leave this legacy to future generations,” he said.
Johnson is a part of a group of environmentalists, academics and American Indian tribes who are gathering force against a nuclear energy revival in the Northwest.
Nuclear energy opponents argue that SMRs are simply a new coat of paint on the industry’s old problems. Like traditional reactors, they say that SMRs aren’t economically feasible and risk exposing people to nuclear radiation in a region still recovering from its World War II legacy.
The X-energy command room in Rockville, Md. Amazon plans to use X-energy’s nuclear reactor design to power its Eastern Oregon data centers.
‘It’s for their profit’
M.V. Ramana’s argument against SMRs is economic as much as it is scientific.
A professor in the School of Public Affairs and Global Policy at the University of British Columbia, Ramana said the global share of electricity generated from nuclear reactors has been shrinking for decades, mainly due to the cost of building them.
Ramana pointed to the U.S.’s newest nuclear reactor project as an example. A nuclear reactor expansion at Plant Vogtle in Georgia went billions of dollars over budget before its first reactor went online in 2023.
Proponents say SMRs could solve the cost problem. At about one-tenth the size of a traditional reactor, SMR parts could be manufactured offsite, a process expected to save considerable money. While SMRs might sacrifice total capacity, their output is anticipated to far exceed other forms of low-carbon energy like solar and wind.
Ramana is skeptical of this argument, too. He said traditional reactors rely on an economy of scale: Their large size carries a great expense but it also means more energy to generate and sell. While an SMR might be one-tenth the size of a traditional reactor, Ramana said not all the costs of running and operating it are going to shrink by the same margin. SMR developers have also yet to realize decreased construction costs, Ramana said. He referenced NuScale, a Portland company whose SMR project in Idaho ballooned its cost 75% to $9.3 billion before it was canceled.
Amazon and other tech companies are backing nuclear as they promote technologies reliant on artificial intelligence because the hardware used to compute that data has extensive energy needs. The International Energy Agency projects data center energy consumption to double from 2022 to 2026. But optimistic timelines for the completion of the Amazon SMRs in Washington estimates they wouldn’t be built for at least seven years. Ramana said that’s enough time for the data demand bubble to burst.
“They need the power right now, because right now is when the market is hot,” he said. “There is no guarantee that in 10 years the market is going to be hot and they will need all this power.”
In a statement, an Amazon spokesperson said it won’t abandon its other green energy efforts as it pursues nuclear projects.
“We will continue to invest in new sources of solar, wind, and energy storage, alongside nuclear facilities … Expanding our energy investment strategy to include other forms of carbon-free energy, including nuclear, is the most viable option to bring new sources of carbon-free energy online quickly enough to help bridge this gap,” the company said in a written statement.
If Amazon and other tech companies were truly interested in protecting the world from climate change, Ramana said, they would take steps to reduce their data businesses rather than growing its energy usage.
“It’s for their profit,” he said. “It is not for the environmental good that they are doing it.”
/
Northwest News Network
The Hanford Site pictured in 2021. Amazon announced in October that it plans to build nuclear reactors in southeast Washington that would power its data centers in Umatilla and Morrow counties, but many tribes and environmentalists are against it.
Hanford’s legacy
Columbia Riverkeeper staff attorney Simone Anter describes Hanford Reach as an idyllic spot, the last undammed, free flowing part of the Columbia River and an important spawning grounds for Chinook salmon.
It’s also near the most nuclear waste polluted area in the Western Hemisphere.
During World War II and the Cold War, the Hanford Site in southeastern Washington was the top producer of weapons-grade plutonium in the U.S. While Hanford stopped producing plutonium in the 1980s, the site left behind hundreds of billions of gallons of nuclear waste in underground storage tanks that leached into the soil.
Anter said Columbia Riverkeeper was formed when two groups worried about nuclear pollution in the Columbia merged.
“A lot of our work centers around this idea that Hanford is not a nuclear waste dumping ground, it is a place that has a future that people want to use and will use,” she said.
Building new nuclear reactors would be a literal barrier to clean-up efforts as new buildings could cover contaminated areas, Antor said. Columbia Riverkeeper is also concerned that SMRs could mean further nuclear pollution in the event of a meltdown.
SMR backers say that the size and technology of these reactors significantly reduces the risk of a meltdown. But even if the reactors avoid meltdowns, Ramana said they would still generate waste that will take hundreds or even thousands of years to decay.
/
OPB
The Nixyaawii Governance Center in Mission, Ore., on April 30, 2024, located in Umatilla County. Confederated Tribes of the Umatilla Indian Reservation has ceded land at Hanford and has opposed SMRs for years.
The tribes respond
Indigenous tribes often bear the brunt of the nuclear energy industry’s follies.
Tribes in the Southwest have long protested uranium mining near their communities, highlighting how radiation exposure has hurt tribal members’ health.
In the Pacific Northwest, the Yakama Nation has religious sites at Hanford and is directly involved in clean-up efforts. The Confederated Tribes of the Umatilla Indian Reservation also has ceded land at Hanford and has opposed SMRs for years. They reiterated their opposition in a December statement, writing that they were against any “expansion of nuclear energy” unless developers sought permission through the CTUIR government
Amazon has spent several years building a relationship with the CTUIR, including the establishment of an educational lab on the Umatilla Indian Reservation in 2022. But the tribes are concerned about how SMRs would affect water quality, fish and game habitat and plant life, all integral parts of the tribes’ First Foods.
Early signs also point to nuclear energy becoming a hot topic at the upcoming legislative session in Salem. State Rep. Bobby Levy, R-Echo, has already said she will sponsor a bill that would authorize an SMR pilot program in Umatilla County. A legislative committee also received a presentation on SMRs from nuclear energy officials in December.
It’s a fight Johnson, who helped curtail the nuclear energy industry by leading the effort to pass Measure 7 in 1980, hasn’t let go.
In the years that followed the measure’s passage, he worked as a fundraiser for Portland State University and Western Oregon University, but Johnson re-engaged with the nuclear issue following the 2011 nuclear power plant meltdown in Fukushima, Japan.
He steered his career track back toward nuclear opposition, becoming a program manager for the International Physicians for the Prevention of Nuclear War, first moving to Boston and then Switzerland to lead the organization’s Geneva office.
Johnson intends to retire later this year and return to Oregon, where he plans to remain active in opposing nuclear energy. He sees the sudden push for SMRs as an act of hubris from the country’s “tech bros,” an unearned confidence that they could unlock the potential of nuclear energy where previous generations have failed. Given the long, uncertain timeline for SMRs, Johnson thinks it’s just a ploy for tech companies to consume however much energy they want, whether it’s low carbon or not.
“I think it’s cynical,” he said. “They’re basically saying, ‘We got a promise to be carbon free, and fortunately for us, it’s something that’s going to take a while to do.’”
Subscribed
ABOUT THE FOLLOWING ACCESS TO LLAW’a ALL THINGS NUCLEAR” RELATED MEDIA:“
(Please note that the Sunday and Saturday NUCLEAR WORLD’S NEWS are also added below by category, following Monday’s news posts in order to maintain continuity of nuclear news as well as for research for the overall information provided in “LLAW;s All Things Nuclear”.)
There are 7 categories, with the latest addition, (#7) being a Friday weekly roundup of IAEA (International Atomic Energy Agency) global nuclear news stories. Also included is a bonus non-nuclear category for news about the Yellowstone caldera and other volcanic and caldera activity around the world that play an important role in humanity’s lives. The feature categories provide articles and information about ‘all things nuclear’ for you to pick from, usually with up to 3 links with headlines concerning the most important media stories in each category, but sometimes fewer and occasionally even none (especially so with the Yellowstone Caldera). The Categories are listed below in their usual order:
- All Things Nuclear
- Nuclear Power
- Nuclear Power Emergencies
- Nuclear War
- Nuclear War Threats
- Yellowstone Caldera (Note: There are three Yellowstone Caldera bonus stories available in today’s Post.)
- IAEA Weekly News (Friday’s only)
Whenever there is an underlined link to a Category media news story, if you press or click on the link provided, you no longer have to cut and paste to your web browser, since this Post’s link will take you directly to the article in your browser.
A current Digest of major nuclear media headlines with automated links is listed below by nuclear Category (in the above listed order). If a Category heading does not appear in the daily news Digest, it means there was no news reported from this Category today. Generally, the three best articles in each Category from around the nuclear world(s) are Posted. Occasionally, if a Post is important enough, it may be listed in multiple Categories.
TODAY’s NUCLEAR WORLD’s NEWS, Tuesday, (01/07/2025)
All Things Nuclear
NEWS
Will the world fall in love with nuclear power once more? – Grist Magazine
Grist Magazine
These fears had originally everything to do with fear of nuclear war and the fear that people would get sick from the fallout. When nuclear plants …
Tribes, environmentalists gather forces against Amazon’s Northwest nuclear plan
Jefferson Public Radio
But the tribes are concerned about how SMRs would affect water quality, fish and game habitat and plant life, all integral parts of the tribes’ First …
Explained: US to scrap curbs on Indian nuclear entities | India-US Nuclear deal – YouTube
YouTube
CNBC New 387K views · 13:49 · Go to channel. 7 Cybersecurity Tips NOBODY Tells You (but are EASY to do). All Things Secured•1.1M views · 1:06:24 · Go …
Nuclear Power
NEWS
Nuclear Energy Generation: A Regional Look – Visual Capitalist
Visual Capitalist
Compared to other energy sources, functioning nuclear reactors produce the fewest emissions per gigawatt hour of any fuel type–less than 1% of …
Exerting Influence: World Nuclear Association in the Media 2024
World Nuclear Association
2024 has been an extraordinary year for nuclear energy in the news, with the Association providing input to top tier media outlets
Nuclear Energy Supply Forecast by Region – Visual Capitalist
Visual Capitalist
As the world transitions toward a greener future, the demand for clean electricity like that produced by nuclear energy creates opportunities globally …
Nuclear Power Emergencies
NEWS
Salem/Hope To Test Sirens, Alert System This Morning – First State Update
First State Update
The Delaware Emergency Management Agency (DEMA) and Delaware State Police will conduct a quarterly test of the Salem/Hope Creek Nuclear Generating …
US governors declare state of emergency amid major winter storm – ABC News
ABC
Governors in Kansas, Kentucky, Arkansas, West Virginia, Virginia and Maryland have declared states of emergency. … Topic:Nuclear Energy. Tue 7 Jan …
Russia declares state of emergency in Crimea following oil spill – SAFETY4SEA
safety4sea
January 3, 2025 · russian nuclear icebreaker · Arctic · Russia receives its fourth nuclear–powered icebreaker · January 3, 2025 · china · Accidents …
Nuclear War
NEWS
To Avoid Nuclear War: America’s Most Important Obligation – Modern Diplomacy
Modern Diplomacy
For the incoming American president, one policy assumption is unchallengeable: If the United States doesn’t manage to avoid a nuclear conflict,
As Ukraine war continues, risk of nuclear war with Russia rises (Viewpoint) – MassLive.com
MassLive.com
That could easily lead to nuclear war, a catastrophe that would affect the whole world. We do more than just provide Ukraine with these missiles; our …
New administration must prep nation for nuclear threat | The Seattle Times
The Seattle Times
Recently, 92-year-old Terumi Tanaka stepped to the podium in Oslo, Norway, to accept the 2024 Nobel Peace Prize. Tanaka was just 13 years old when …
Nuclear War Threats
NEWS
Doomsday Clock reset imminent amid Israel-Hamas war and threats from Iran, North Korea …
New York Post
Russian President Vladimir Putin’s threats to use nuclear weapons in Urkaine are putting global powers in 6. Russian President Vladimir Putin’s …
New administration must prep nation for nuclear threat | The Seattle Times
The Seattle Times
During the Cold War, the threat of nuclear annihilation was always- and ever-present. In those days, Americans managed the fear in the simplest …
Lessons from South Africa: A New Strategy for Iran’s Nuclear Threat
Center for Arms Control and Non-Proliferation
Lessons from South Africa: A New Strategy for Iran’s Nuclear Threat … Iran is closer than ever to acquiring nuclear weapons. The risks to the ..
Yellowstone Caldera
NEWS
Looking Back On Geological Activity In Yellowstone During 2024 – National Parks Traveler
National Parks Traveler
Yellowstone Caldera continued to subside at a rate of a few centimeters (1–2 inches) per year, temporarily interrupted during the summer months by …
Will Yellowstone Erupt Soon? Scientists Are Using New Techniques to Find Out
Smithsonian Magazine
Though basaltic eruptions are more common worldwide, the Yellowstone Caldera was formed by a rhyolitic eruption that launched magma with the same …
Yellowstone Won’t Erupt Anytime Soon, Scientists Confirm – Yahoo
Yahoo
A close look at the supervolcano’s plumbing reveals a lack of magma necessary for a massive eruption.